« When three strong candidates make the shortlist, the decision often comes down to one question. What does the company need most in the first twelve months? For a subsidiary managing director, the priority might be to restore profitability, build a stronger management team or grow the client portfolio. Three experienced candidates may bring different strengths to those challenges. An impressive track record and a persuasive interview each offer useful evidence, and the decision ultimately hinges on how well that evidence matches the brief.

At Phénicia Conseil, an international recruitment firm that has supported companies across Africa and the Middle East for more than twenty years, comparing finalists is part of the firm’s advisory work. The comparison draws on the priorities agreed with the client, documented achievements and the conditions each candidate needs to succeed. In Europe–Africa recruitment, it also considers the context in which candidates achieved their results and their ability to deliver similar results in another organisation. »

 

  1. Define the Role’s Priorities

The process starts with the recruitment brief. For an executive role, the recruiter and the client need to agree on the decisions the new leader will be expected to make, the resources they will have at their disposal and the results they should deliver by the end of their first year. These factors determine how much weight each criterion carries on the candidate assessment scorecard.

Consider a fictional case. A European group is recruiting a managing director for its industrial services subsidiary in Abidjan. The business has doubled its headcount in three years. Revenue has grown, but margins have declined and delivery delays have increased. Headquarters expects the new leader to improve profitability, give managers clearer accountability and overhaul the way operations are run. The managing director will also need to retain key accounts. The company already has an established sales team.

Profitability, operational delivery and team management therefore account for 65 points out of 100. If the brief called for entering a new market, building a team and developing a client portfolio from scratch, business development would carry more weight. The client agrees on these priorities before the final interviews so that all candidates are assessed against the same criteria.

 

  1. Check the Essential Requirements

A recruitment shortlist should show which requirements every candidate must meet and which competencies can be compared on a scoring scale. In this case, the recruiter verifies the same requirements for all three finalists: the ability to work in Abidjan and travel as required, professional proficiency in French and English, and compensation expectations within the approved budget. Availability and compensation still need to align with the brief, even when a candidate scores highly on business development.

For each requirement, the candidate file can indicate confirmed, to be verified or does not meet the requirement. Record the exact issue that still needs to be resolved. “Start date to be confirmed after reviewing the notice period” gives the recruiter a specific point to follow up on. “Relocation uncertain” leaves the practical issue open. Questions about mobility focus on the requirements of the role, including the start date, work location and travel.

In this example, all three candidates meet the essential requirements. The comparison therefore focuses on their ability to deliver on the brief and on the support they may need when they take up the role.

 

  1. Weight the Assessment Criteria

The scorecard below translates the subsidiary managing director’s brief into observable criteria. The finance team can help define the profitability measures, and operations leaders can specify what good delivery looks like on the ground.

Criterion Weight Evidence to assess
Financial management and profitability 25 Profit and loss responsibility, actions to improve margins, cost control and monitoring of cash collections.
Team leadership and organisational structure 20 Team size and composition, delegation decisions, development of managers and performance monitoring.
Operational delivery 20 How the candidate organises operations, meets client commitments, manages delays and addresses recurring problems.
Business development 15 Account retention, contract negotiation and ability to grow profitable business.
Adaptation to local and cross-cultural working environments 10 Examples of how the candidate adapted their practices to a different working environment and the results they achieved.
Governance and relationship with headquarters 10 Quality of reporting, handling of trade-offs and escalation of information that supports decisions.
Total 100

All assessors use the same scale. 1 means the candidate falls short of the role’s requirements, 2 means they partially meet them, 3 means they meet expectations, 4 indicates strong capability and 5 indicates particularly strong capability demonstrated in a comparable setting. When the available evidence is insufficient to assign a score, mark the criterion further evidence required. A follow-up question, a case exercise or a reference check can help fill the gap.

For a criterion worth 25 points, a rating of 4 out of 5 earns 20 points. Each assessor records their ratings and supporting evidence before the debrief. Where ratings differ, the panel can examine the reason. Did the assessors focus on the same facts? Did they interpret what the candidate meant by “leading” a team in the same way?

 

  1. Compare Three Finalists

Candidate A — Strengthening operations. He led a technical services business in West Africa. He describes how he introduced operational reviews, clarified which decisions belonged to the local head office and which sat with the sites, and supported his frontline managers. He shows how delays decreased using metrics tracked over several months. His commercial experience centres on retaining existing accounts. The final interview should explore his ability to lead a strategic negotiation himself.

Candidate B — Restoring profitability. He ran an industrial subsidiary with full profit and loss responsibility. He explains how he analysed profitability by contract, revised pricing for selected services and improved the monitoring of cash collections. He also gives strong examples of team leadership. The final interview should establish how he supported teams through these changes and how he assessed their impact on service quality.

Candidate C — Developing the market. He built a portfolio of industrial clients, negotiated complex contracts and worked with local teams and a European headquarters. He explains how he adapted his approach across several markets and earned the trust of different stakeholders. His examples show that he operated with the degree of autonomy the role requires. His ability to secure a prompt decision from headquarters when a budget dispute arises warrants further discussion.

Criterion Maximum Candidate A Candidate B Candidate C
Financial management and profitability 25 20 25 20
Team leadership and organisational structure 20 20 16 16
Operational delivery 20 20 16 16
Business development 15 9 12 15
Adaptation to local and cross-cultural working environments 10 8 8 10
Governance and relationship with headquarters 10 8 8 6
Total 100 85 85 83

The scores are illustrative. A and B finish level, with different strengths. A is better placed to improve operational delivery and develop frontline managers. B provides stronger evidence of turning around financial performance. C is two points behind and has the strongest commercial profile. The cause of the subsidiary’s difficulties determines how to interpret those scores. If delays and rework are the main reasons margins have declined, A’s operational experience carries particular weight. If pricing, contract terms and collections are the main drivers, B’s track record addresses the need more directly. C becomes a particularly strong option if the client confirms that winning back business is a priority.

 

  1. Use the Final Interview to Decide

A structured final interview combines common questions with targeted follow-ups. Each candidate receives the same case materials, with the same information and preparation time. The recruiter records the decisions each candidate proposes, the reasoning behind them and the assumptions that need to be tested.

Common question What to assess
You take over a subsidiary where margins are falling and delays are mounting. What would you examine in your first thirty days? Quality of the diagnosis, order of priorities and ability to identify missing data.
A key client asks for a discount to renew a contract that already generates little profit. How would you approach the decision? Ability to weigh profitability, the client relationship, delivery capacity and room for negotiation.
Headquarters wants rapid cost savings, and the local team is concerned that service will suffer. What would you propose, and how would you secure a decision? Quality of communication with headquarters and local teams, decision criteria and follow-up on the impact.

Individual follow-ups address specific points raised during shortlisting. Ask A to describe the last client negotiation he personally led, what authority he had to make concessions and what outcome he achieved. Ask B what decisions he took when a cost-reduction plan ran into difficulties on the ground and how he monitored service quality. Ask C for an example of a situation where he needed a quick decision from headquarters and what he did while waiting.

A response carries more weight when the candidate can describe the context, their role, the resources available, the decisions they took and the results they observed. In cross-cultural recruitment, this method also helps assess careers built in different working environments. Specific examples show how candidates understood local working practices and adjusted their approach.

 

  1. Make a Recommendation

A recruitment firm’s recommendation should explain why it is putting a candidate forward, what evidence supports the choice and what remains to be confirmed. In the Abidjan example, if the client’s diagnosis traces the losses to delivery delays and the way teams are organised, Phénicia Conseil would recommend Candidate A as its first choice. His achievements match the immediate priority. The final interview would help establish the depth of his commercial experience. If his examples show that he mainly supported colleagues who led negotiations, his onboarding could include working with the commercial lead on key accounts from the outset.

A reference check, conducted with the candidate’s consent, can add evidence at this stage. It can clarify how much autonomy A had in leading operational change, how long the improvements held and what he contributed to key-account relationships. The firm can then link what it assessed during recruitment to the objectives for the first few months. In this scenario, follow-ups at 30, 60 and 90 days would focus on the quality of the operational assessment, the clarification of managers’ responsibilities and the initial steps taken to reduce delays.

 

  1. Frequently Asked Questions

How many candidates should be on a recruitment shortlist? Three candidates provide a basis for comparison when each meets the requirements of the role. The number depends on the strength of the applications and the constraints of the assignment. Two strong candidates can be enough when the available information supports a reasoned decision.

Should you hire the candidate with the highest score? The score helps identify strengths, differences and areas that need further verification. When two candidates score closely, the decision depends principally on first-year priorities, the strength of the evidence and the support each candidate may need when taking up the role.

Can you use the same scorecard for every executive search? The structure is reusable. Tailor the criteria, their weights and the evidence you expect to the brief. A subsidiary managing director entering a new market, a plant director stabilising production and a managing director preparing for a leadership handover have different priorities.

Are you hiring an executive for a subsidiary in Africa? Phénicia Conseil works with senior leadership and HR teams to define the recruitment brief, approach candidates directly and assess finalists. Talk to us about what you expect your new executive to achieve and what criteria will guide your decision.