« Two finalists have strong track records. One describes how they reduced delivery delays at an industrial services subsidiary. The other explains how they restored margins at a comparable business. Before making a decision, senior management needs to understand what each candidate personally led, what resources they had and which results lasted. Professional reference checks tailored to the hiring brief help establish these facts with people who observed the candidates’ work firsthand.
In international executive recruitment, there is a further consideration. A subsidiary managing director may have had considerable discretion over pricing, hiring or investment in a previous role. In the new organisation, those decisions may require approval from headquarters. Reference checks help establish how the candidate worked in their previous setting and what conditions would help them succeed in the new one.
At Phénicia Conseil, an international recruitment consultancy that has supported companies across Africa and the Middle East for more than twenty years, reference checks build on competency-based interviews and the assessment of shortlisted candidates. They help clients make a decision they can explain and prepare for the executive’s first months in the role. »
-
Start with the hiring brief
Before preparing the call, review what the new executive is expected to deliver. For a subsidiary that needs to restore profitability, the central question may be whether the candidate can identify the causes of declining margins, make timely decisions and bring their teams on board. For a new operation, the priorities may include building the team, winning the first client accounts or establishing reporting arrangements with headquarters.
Once those priorities are clear, revisit the interview evidence. Identify the claims that matter most to the decision and pinpoint what you want to verify. If the candidate says they “restructured operations”, a referee can help establish what changed, which decisions the candidate made personally and when the effects became visible. A broad claim such as “they turned the subsidiary around” could involve changing prices, ending loss-making contracts, improving collections or increasing output. Each calls for a different question.
Choose two or three priorities before the call. For each one, record what the candidate said, the question you plan to ask and the type of evidence that would help the client decide. This keeps the conversation focused and makes it easier to compare finalists.
-
Choose the right referees
The right referee is someone who saw the candidate’s work in the area you want to explore. A former line manager can clarify the remit, the targets set and the authority granted. A former finance lead can explain the candidate’s contribution to a recovery in margins. A former direct report can describe how the executive assigned responsibilities, supported managers and followed up on decisions at site level.
| Area to explore | Who to speak to | What they can clarify |
|---|---|---|
| Scope of responsibility | Former line manager or executive at headquarters | Delegated authority, decisions requiring approval, objectives and resources. |
| Financial turnaround | Former finance director or financial controller at the subsidiary | What drove the change in margins, the candidate’s contribution and the period covered. |
| Operational delivery | Former operations manager or site director | Measures implemented, changes in delivery times and whether improvements lasted. |
| Team management | Former direct report | Delegation, support for managers and handling of disagreements. |
| Working with headquarters | Former headquarters colleague who worked with the candidate | Quality of reporting, handling of escalated issues and preparation for decisions. |
Agree with the candidate on whom to contact and when. If the job search is confidential, choose referees from previous roles together. At the start of the call, ask how long the referee worked with the candidate, in what capacity and how often. Someone who attended a monthly committee meeting and a manager who worked with the executive every day can offer complementary perspectives on the same situation.
-
Ask for specific examples
“Would you recommend this person?” can be a useful closing question. To assess suitability for the role, begin with specific situations. Ask what the referee observed, how they tracked results and who else contributed to the project. Prepare a few common questions so you can compare candidates, along with follow-up questions about each person’s achievements.
| Criterion | Question to ask | Evidence to gather |
|---|---|---|
| Personal contribution | Which decision did the candidate make themselves on this project? | The responsibility they held, a specific decision and the contribution of others. |
| Decision-making authority | Which decisions could they make locally, and which required approval from headquarters? | Delegated authority, approval thresholds and decision turnaround times. |
| Results | Which indicators did you track, and over what period did you see a change? | The starting point, the indicator, the time frame and whether progress was sustained. |
| Management | How did they respond when a manager challenged an important decision? | How they handled the disagreement, delegated responsibilities and followed up. |
| Cross-cultural adaptability | Can you describe a time when they changed how they ran a project to work with teams or a head office accustomed to different ways of working? | A specific situation, the change in approach and its observed effects. |
| Conditions for success | What resources or support enabled them to achieve those results? | Team capacity, access to data, support from headquarters and budget discretion. |
A good follow-up asks what happened in practice. If the referee says the candidate “got the team moving again”, ask what changed day to day. Did managers start making decisions on site? Did operational reviews help resolve incidents earlier? Were commitments to clients met more consistently? If the data is confidential, invite the referee to describe the type of metric, the direction of change and the period covered without disclosing figures.
-
Weight the evidence
A reference check framework can help HR directors prioritise their questions. The illustrative weightings below apply to a subsidiary managing director tasked with improving profitability, stabilising operations and giving managers greater responsibility. They guide the order and emphasis of the checks. Shortlist scores and reference findings each inform the hiring decision.
| Area to verify | Suggested weighting | Evidence to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Operational and financial results | 30% | Changes tracked over time and the factors that contributed to the results. |
| Personal contribution and decision-making authority | 25% | Decisions attributable to the candidate and the approvals required. |
| Team management and development | 20% | An example of delegation or coaching that changed how the team worked. |
| Governance and relations with headquarters | 15% | A documented decision made with headquarters and follow-up on its implementation. |
| Cross-cultural adaptability | 10% | An observable adjustment in working methods to suit a team or organisation. |
| Total | 100% |
A claim is corroborated when a referee who was directly involved describes a situation consistent with the interview and can clarify the candidate’s role or the results they observed. It is partially corroborated when the referee saw only part of the project. It requires further review when the referee did not observe the situation firsthand or a significant factual discrepancy remains.
Consider what each referee was in a position to observe. A former finance director may have tracked margins without attending meetings with site managers. A former manager may have seen changes to day-to-day operations without having access to the financial figures. Record what each person could observe before drawing conclusions about the candidate.
-
Compare two finalists in Abidjan
Consider the illustrative case from the shortlist article. A European group is recruiting a managing director for its industrial services subsidiary in Abidjan. Delays are increasing and margins are falling. Two finalists each score 85 out of 100 on the shortlist scorecard. Candidate A stands out for improving how operations and teams are organised. Candidate B has stronger financial turnaround experience.
| Finalist | Point to verify | Reference check question | Potential implication for the decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| A — Operational restructuring | Did the candidate personally introduce new management practices and give site managers more authority? | What decisions did they make to reduce delays, and how did you track progress over several months? | If delays and rework are driving losses, this evidence strengthens Candidate A’s fit with the subsidiary’s priorities. |
| B — Financial turnaround | Did the candidate lead the measures that improved profitability and track their impact on service? | Which measures did they personally lead to restore margins, and what results were still visible six months later? | If pricing, contracts and collections account for most of the difficulties, Candidate B’s experience more directly fits the brief. |
Suppose Candidate A’s former operations manager confirms that the candidate introduced weekly reviews and delegated certain decisions to site managers, and that delays fell over several months. These facts corroborate the candidate’s operational achievements. If the referee had little involvement in commercial negotiations, the recruitment consultancy can follow up with someone who worked directly on key accounts.
For Candidate B, a former finance director may confirm that the candidate introduced contract-level margin tracking, renegotiated service agreements and improved collections. They may also explain that major pricing decisions required approval from headquarters. The client can compare this experience with the authority planned for the Abidjan role and clarify who will decide on priority renegotiations when the executive takes up the post.
The recommendation ultimately depends on what is driving the subsidiary’s losses. If the relative impact of delays, rework and underpriced contracts remains unclear, the consultancy can ask the client to identify the main sources of loss. The comparison is more informative when the company knows which problem the new executive needs to address first.
-
Use the findings
A reference check summary can be brief. Record the professional relationship between the candidate and the referee, the period covered, the facts reported, any open questions and their implications for the decision. A statement such as “the referee confirms that the candidate led operational reviews and tracked delivery times with site managers” gives the hiring committee a concrete fact to work with.
When two accounts differ, revisit the dates, responsibilities and circumstances. A former line manager may have seen a decision proposed at a committee meeting, while a former site manager saw its effects several months later. Ask for a specific example. If the discrepancy concerns a deciding factor, give the candidate an opportunity to clarify their contribution or the circumstances of the assignment.
The summary can also inform onboarding. If Candidate A is appointed in Abidjan, early check-ins can cover the causes of delays, the authority delegated to site managers and coordination with the sales director on key accounts. If Candidate B is appointed, discussions can focus on profitability by contract, how decisions with headquarters are made and which indicators track service quality. Linking the assessment to objectives for the first few months gives the client and the executive specific commitments to review together.
-
Frequently asked questions
When should you conduct professional reference checks?
They typically take place towards the end of the hiring process, after a structured interview and before the final decision. The consultancy can then focus its questions on the achievements, responsibilities and working conditions that matter for the role.
How many references should you request for a senior executive?
Two referees with complementary perspectives are a starting point. A former line manager can clarify the candidate’s decision-making authority, while a finance director or former direct report can provide evidence of results or management practices. A third conversation can help when a deciding factor remains unresolved.
What if the candidate is currently employed?
Agree with the candidate on whom to contact and when. Referees from previous roles can often answer priority questions, especially when the candidate is exploring a move confidentially.
How should you handle a mixed reference?
Ask the referee to describe the situation, when it happened and what followed. Consider how it relates to the current brief. If the point is decisive for the role, explore it with the candidate and, where appropriate, with a second referee who observed the situation firsthand.
What should you ask when recruiting internationally?
Ask about local decision-making authority, collaboration with headquarters, how teams were organised and a situation in which the candidate adapted their working practices. These questions help establish the conditions in which the candidate turned their skills into results.
Are you hiring a subsidiary managing director or senior executive in Africa? Phénicia Conseil supports HR directors and senior management from defining the brief through to assessing finalists and following up during onboarding. Let’s discuss what your new executive needs to deliver and what to verify before you decide.
Recent Comments